Revolutionizing Performance Reviews: A Focus on Employee Learning and Growth

Let's face it: the traditional annual performance review process is often a source of dread for both employees and managers. Why? Could it be that it is focused on the past not the future. When faced with an annual performance review, employees worry that it will be a microscope for their past mistakes and managers struggle to remember what happened further than 4 weeks in the past. But what if the process was completely transformed—moving away from a transactional, year-end chore to a development tool that promoted engagement, and continuous learning?

Imagine a performance management program that puts the employee's growth front and center, is an easy lift for managers, and promotes better performance.

If your current process feels stuck in the past and you lack any motivation to go through yet another review cycle read on.

The Cost of the Annual 'Look-Back'

Many existing performance reviews processes are relics of the past—created decade ago and primarily designed to document the past. The biggest flaw is that they spend most of the time reviewing what has happened over the last twelve months and very little on future goals and developmental plans. To be meaningful and relevant they must concentrate on future performance, with goals and development plans front and center.

Humans have a notoriously poor memory for the accurate recollection of the past, often resulting in inaccurate performance evaluation. Several factors add to our inability to recall information accurately including:

• Recency bias: This is our inability to retrieve information after extended periods of time. We therefore rely on the most recent information available.

• Confirmation bias: We look for information that supports our current beliefs (accurate or inaccurate).

• Subsequent misinformation received after the event has taken place clouds the perspective of the event as it actually happened.

Biased toward recent events, and missing actionable feedback performance reviews are demotivating and ineffective, resulting in increased employee disengagement. Furthermore, lengthy look backs that result in performance improvement plans or corrective actions can open the company to legal exposure. If the employee was not made aware of the performance issue prior to the annual review or given the opportunity to correct the problem they may have grounds for a claim against the employer.

While you may not be able to completely discard your company's mandated annual form, you absolutely can supplement the process to create a far superior, future-focused experience that your employees will appreciate and even look forward to.

Flip the Script

One of the most meaningful changes to make is to move away from a single annual discussion and hold frequent, structured check-ins. At a minimum, managers should meet with each employee quarterly to discuss current performance and projects as well as lay out plans for the upcoming quarter including goals and professional development.

Meeting quarterly provides a current, realistic, and actionable picture of performance. If a developmental opportunity or a performance correction is needed, it must be addressed sooner than twelve months later. Waiting for the annual review is how employees get blindsided by issues that happened long ago and were never addressed at the time—a situation that actively undermines trust and the manager’s ability to act as a coach.

A Partnership for Growth

There is a better way to handle reviews, and it doesn't have to be a heavy lift for managers. The key is transforming the process into a living document for learning and development, with the employee generating critical information.

When the performance discussion is built around the employee's input, it immediately generates buy-in and ensures the conversation is centered on the work they actually do, not just an outdated job description. This shift combats the common complaint of managers being "out of touch" and ensures employees feel valued for their contributions and potential.

An Efficient Process Focused on Development

This approach is easy to implement and yields significant returns in employee engagement and development. Here are the four steps:

1. Create Quarterly Conversation Plan

Create a simple set of open-ended questions that prompt the employee to reflect on the past 3 months and plan for the upcoming quarter. The narrative format avoids a rating system and encourages deeper self-reflection and ownership. This short simple questionnaire is sent to each employee quarterly for completion. This reduces the workload of the managers and is a more accurate reflection of the employees’ performance.

Sample Development-Focused Review Questions:

• Look Back (90 Days):

  • What were your major accomplishments in the past 90 days? Include completed projects, challenges overcome, and skills you developed or improved.

  • Describe any problems you experienced and how you resolved them. What did you learn from that process?

    
    

As you can see, these questions are focused on what the employee experienced and learned as a result of those experiences. Making learning the goal of challenges the employee encountered.

• Look Ahead (Next 90 Days):

  • What are your upcoming projects and goals for the next 90 days? (e.g., progress on annual goals, specific skills you would like to update or acquire, projects you are interested in leading).

  • How can I, as your manager, support your learning and development to achieve these goals?

  • What resources (training, time, mentorship) do you need from me or the company?

These questions address not only past performance but growth and forward vision. Giving a positive look at the future that in turn promotes engagement.

2. Establish a Predictable Schedule

Notify staff of the set quarterly dates for the questionnaire distribution and the required completion date. Consistency and transparency are critical to the success of this process.

3. Schedule Performance and Development Meetings

Set 15-20 minute follow-up meetings for each employee every quarter to review the self-assessment. At this time the manager will share their review of the employees performance as well as upcoming plans for the department. The focus in these meetings is on the discussion and coaching. Opening lines of communication and giving the employee a voice.

4. Integrate Quarterly Data into the Annual Review

Managers can now use the documented quarterly discussions and the employees’ narrative responses as the foundation for the annual performance document. This makes the annual review a simple compilation and final check-in, rather than a demanding writing exercise that managers and employee’s dread.

A New Role: Coach and Developer

By implementing this process, you are fundamentally changing the manager's role from a writer of history to a forwarding looking coach and employee development partner. One focused on helping people advance their careers within the organization.

Aligning Goals and Purpose

A critical component in this process is explaining the company's mission and vision in a way that fosters a sense of purpose and meaning for the employee. People want to know their work makes a tangible difference. Creating this alignment as part of the quarterly conversation helps ensure the employee’s personal development goals are in sync with the organization's strategic needs.

While this approach may seem to be time-consuming, in actuality it reduces the time managers spend trying to create an accurate review of the past 12 months. The increased time investment is done by the employees and allows managers to reallocate their time investment to performance check-in conversations where employees now feel heard and an active part of their performance planning. Most importantly, the quality of information you glean—not to mention the renewed engagement and motivation of your employees—is invaluable.

This strategic investment in your staff gives them a powerful voice in their work and development, establishes a deeper, coaching-focused connection, allowing morale, learning, and productivity of the team to soar.

Ready to Advance Your HR/L&D Strategy? Subscribe to DEVELOP, the must-read magazine that put you at the intersection of Learning & Development and HR.

Delivered directly to your inbox quarterly. The first edition arrives January 2026!

Sign me up!